top of page

How to Screen for Reliable Renters

Updated: Sep 6, 2023

Finding reliable renters is crucial for any landlord or property manager. A reliable tenant pays rent on time, respects the property, and communicates effectively. However, identifying such tenants requires a thorough screening process. In this blog post, we will explore essential steps and strategies to screen for reliable renters who will be an asset to your rental property.

1. Establish Clear Tenant Criteria

Before you begin the screening process, define your tenant criteria. Decide on factors like the minimum credit score, income requirement, rental history, and any specific preferences you may have. Having clear criteria in place will help you make consistent and fair decisions.

2. Request a Rental Application

Require all prospective tenants to complete a comprehensive rental application. This document should collect essential information such as employment history, rental history, personal references, and income details. Ensure that the application is complete, accurate, and signed by the applicant.

3. Conduct a Credit Check

A credit check is a valuable tool for assessing a tenant's financial responsibility. Request permission to run a credit check as part of your screening process. Look for a credit score that meets your predetermined criteria, as well as any significant negative items such as unpaid debts or bankruptcy.

4. Verify Employment and Income

Contact the applicant's current employer to verify their employment status, job stability, and income. This helps you determine if the tenant can comfortably afford the rent. Typically, landlords look for tenants with a monthly income at least three times the monthly rent.

5. Contact Previous Landlords

Contact the applicant's previous landlords to gather information about their rental history. Inquire about their payment history, adherence to lease terms, and any issues related to property damage or disturbances. Reliable renters usually have a track record of being respectful and responsible tenants.

6. Check for Criminal Background

Perform a criminal background check to ensure the safety of your property and other tenants. While a minor offense may not be a cause for rejection, be cautious if there is a history of serious criminal activity.

7. Evaluate Rental References

Request personal and professional references from the applicant. Contact these references to gain insight into the tenant's character, reliability, and trustworthiness. Speaking to previous landlords or employers can provide valuable information.

8. Assess Their Communication Skills

During the application and screening process, assess the tenant's communication skills. Reliable renters are typically responsive, clear, and cooperative in their interactions with you.

9. Look for Consistency

Examine the applicant's rental history for signs of consistency. Frequent moves or gaps in rental history may indicate potential issues. On the other hand, a stable rental history suggests reliability.

10. Trust Your Instincts

Lastly, trust your instincts and impressions of the applicant. A personal meeting or interview can reveal a lot about an individual's personality and character. If you have concerns or doubts, it's essential to address them before making a decision.

Screening for reliable renters is a critical aspect of successful property management. While thorough screening can take time and effort, it ultimately pays off by reducing the risk of late payments, property damage, and conflicts. By following these steps and conducting a comprehensive evaluation of prospective tenants, you can identify reliable renters who will contribute positively to your rental property and create a hassle-free rental experience for both parties.


bottom of page